Women - differences in culture
If you're looking of how to finish your homework, you won't find it here!
---
After reconsidering what it is that a woman's role is in society with 'Self Made Man', I have been dumbstruck after reading a third into Xinran's 'The Good Women of China'. Yes, perhaps it was partially to do with the difference in style, but what shocked me the most was the difference in perception of women by these two women who were concerned (or are rather) about women.
What caught me off surprise was the fact that both were two very well educated, articulate women, but both had surprisingly varied ideas (or at least they articulated them different through suggestion) about the ideas of women in their particular country.
China and America. Two very large, two very different countries. I will not deny it, women still have a long way to go when it comes to the equality and the glass ceiling of employment.
It's funny how Xinran, talked about a young lady in her book, a university student, and saw her power (and somewhat feminist views of women) to be a result of a repression of emotion of an entire generation. It is not a criticism, it is an observation. She said this herself. I'm part of this generation. Now the question is, are we really a repressed generation? Have we slipped from emotional go-go to emotional no-go with our busy, over scheduled lives? Have we swapped romance for quick emails? Is it that easy to generalize?
I don't think so. I'm not sure whether our generation is more repressed or not as a result of ... well, a change of lifestyle. Our knowledge. Our need for security, our 'material world'.
Back to the differences. It is obvious that cultural differences will set these two books apart. Jones' talks about how women expect men to be more emotional, she talks about how men expect a wife to be a wife, and get a mistress to fulfill their 'madonna/whore' complexes. They then have both. Wife and mistress. Xinran does the same. Asian women are expected to be 'meek, gentle, shy, sweet', sexy ain't doing it. Sexy doesn't come into the picture in her generation. They got reported for doing that sort of thing during her time. It's frightening.
The Uni student provides an interesting lever for a topic. Here was a modern, Chinese woman, confident and bright. Xinran looks at her like a foreign student would look at a tourist attraction for the first time - unfamiliarity. Xinran comes from a different world. Sexuality, sex and all that jazz was something she had to be careful of, particuarly with censorship. And the uni student was the epitome of the new age open-let's-talk-about-it-now kind of girl. Which, is really more ideal.
I was fascinated with the stereotypical traits Asian women were coined with, and the differences and contrasts that Jones' talked about with women in America and western culture.
At this point in time, I began to ask myself, 'what the hell am I?'. Here I am, an Asian chick happy to be born in a western and somewhat Americanized culture. It frightened me to think about the stereotypes of Asian women, their 'submissive, soft, gentle nature'. I was nothing in this stereotype. I didn't fit this key at all. At the same time, I'm not exactly the go - getting bitch in heels that everyone expects to kow-down to when men decide to take advantage of another woman's good will. I don't need labels, but it is interesting to think of yourself as a product of a very mixed and somewhat contradictive blending of two cultures.
I've decided, in order to keep this alive I will ask women in general what they think it is to be a woman.
---
After reconsidering what it is that a woman's role is in society with 'Self Made Man', I have been dumbstruck after reading a third into Xinran's 'The Good Women of China'. Yes, perhaps it was partially to do with the difference in style, but what shocked me the most was the difference in perception of women by these two women who were concerned (or are rather) about women.
What caught me off surprise was the fact that both were two very well educated, articulate women, but both had surprisingly varied ideas (or at least they articulated them different through suggestion) about the ideas of women in their particular country.
China and America. Two very large, two very different countries. I will not deny it, women still have a long way to go when it comes to the equality and the glass ceiling of employment.
It's funny how Xinran, talked about a young lady in her book, a university student, and saw her power (and somewhat feminist views of women) to be a result of a repression of emotion of an entire generation. It is not a criticism, it is an observation. She said this herself. I'm part of this generation. Now the question is, are we really a repressed generation? Have we slipped from emotional go-go to emotional no-go with our busy, over scheduled lives? Have we swapped romance for quick emails? Is it that easy to generalize?
I don't think so. I'm not sure whether our generation is more repressed or not as a result of ... well, a change of lifestyle. Our knowledge. Our need for security, our 'material world'.
Back to the differences. It is obvious that cultural differences will set these two books apart. Jones' talks about how women expect men to be more emotional, she talks about how men expect a wife to be a wife, and get a mistress to fulfill their 'madonna/whore' complexes. They then have both. Wife and mistress. Xinran does the same. Asian women are expected to be 'meek, gentle, shy, sweet', sexy ain't doing it. Sexy doesn't come into the picture in her generation. They got reported for doing that sort of thing during her time. It's frightening.
The Uni student provides an interesting lever for a topic. Here was a modern, Chinese woman, confident and bright. Xinran looks at her like a foreign student would look at a tourist attraction for the first time - unfamiliarity. Xinran comes from a different world. Sexuality, sex and all that jazz was something she had to be careful of, particuarly with censorship. And the uni student was the epitome of the new age open-let's-talk-about-it-now kind of girl. Which, is really more ideal.
I was fascinated with the stereotypical traits Asian women were coined with, and the differences and contrasts that Jones' talked about with women in America and western culture.
At this point in time, I began to ask myself, 'what the hell am I?'. Here I am, an Asian chick happy to be born in a western and somewhat Americanized culture. It frightened me to think about the stereotypes of Asian women, their 'submissive, soft, gentle nature'. I was nothing in this stereotype. I didn't fit this key at all. At the same time, I'm not exactly the go - getting bitch in heels that everyone expects to kow-down to when men decide to take advantage of another woman's good will. I don't need labels, but it is interesting to think of yourself as a product of a very mixed and somewhat contradictive blending of two cultures.
I've decided, in order to keep this alive I will ask women in general what they think it is to be a woman.
